Top 10 Worst Valentine's Day Gifts You Should Never Give

Valentine’s Day is a day about love and appreciation, but let’s face it—choosing the wrong gift can turn a romantic moment into an awkward one. That’s why, Personal Chic has put together a list of the top 10 worst Valentine’s Day gifts to help you steer clear of common mistakes. Inspired by real-life stories of Valentine’s Day blunders, this guide is here to save you from giving gifts that could do more harm than good. 

Worst Gifts To Give on Valentine's Day - Re-gifted Items

Re-gifting can be a bit of a red flag, especially if you re-gift something that isn’t quite right for your partner. My friend once opened a box of chocolates, only to find a “Merry Christmas” card still tucked inside—it was obvious the gift was an afterthought.

Instead, consider putting thought into a personalised gift, like a custom photo canvas or a handcrafted item, which shows that you took the time to find something special just for them on Valentine’s Day.

Flowers from a Petrol Station

Flowers are classic Valentine’s Day gifts, but last-minute bouquets bought at a petrol station are a dead giveaway that no effort was made. They can come across as a lazy afterthought rather than a romantic gesture, making one of the worst Valentine's day gifts.

A better alternative is to order fresh flowers in advance or choose a plant they can nurture, adding a personal touch with their favourite colours or blooms.

Top 10 Worst Valentine's Day Gifts - Flowers from a Petrol Station

Cheap Lingerie

While lingerie can be a sensual gift on Valentine’s Day, giving inexpensive or ill-fitting lingerie can backfire. Not only can it make the recipient feel uncomfortable, but it can also imply that you didn’t consider their preferences or body type. I’ve heard from a friend that her partner once gave her cheap lingerie, which she never wore. It didn’t fit well, and it didn’t make her feel confident.

Rather than opting for low-quality lingerie, consider something more thoughtful, like a luxurious robe. Gifts like these show your partner that you want them to feel appreciated and loved, rather than pressured into fitting a particular image.

Expired or Discounted Chocolates

Chocolates are a classic Valentine gift, but expired or discounted chocolates can give the impression that you didn’t put much thought into your present. I once heard about a couple who exchanged Valentine's gifts, and one person received a box of half-priced chocolates that were a little past their expiry date. Needless to say, it wasn't received well. 

Instead of opting for bargain chocolates, go for something high-quality or even artisanal that shows you care about their enjoyment. Even if you’re on a budget, a box of handmade chocolates would be a much better option.

Top 10 Worst Valentine's Day Gifts - Expired or Discounted Chocolates

Pet without Prior Discussion

Pets are wonderful, but they’re a huge responsibility and should never be given as a surprise gift without prior discussion. A friend of mine once received a kitten as an unexpected Valentine’s gift. While she adored cats, the lack of preparation and sudden commitment turned what should have been a joyful moment into a stressful experience. 

A more thoughtful alternative could have been something related to her love for cats, like a donation to an animal charity in her name or a personalised cat mug she could cherish every day. These kinds of gifts celebrate her interests without adding undue pressure or responsibility.

Overly Practical Tools

While a wrench set or frying pan might seem thoughtful for someone who loves fixing things or cooking, these are the worst Valentine’s Day gifts as they lack the emotional connection Valentine’s Day deserves. Romance should take centre stage, and practical items often lack emotional significance.

Instead, focus on something that aligns with their hobbies in a more romantic way, like a cooking class or a handmade meal to share together.

Top 10 Worst Valentine's Gifts - Overly Practical Tools

Generic Gift Cards

While practical, generic gift cards are the worst Valentine's gifts as they can feel impersonal and uninspired. One woman shared how her partner handed her a generic £20 gift card, which made her question if he put any thought into the day. Instead, opt for a more personalised option, like a voucher for their favourite shop or an experience gift card for a fun outing that you two can enjoy together.

Exercise Equipment

Unrequested fitness gear, like a set of weights or a yoga mat, are one of the worst Valentine’s Day gifts as they can unintentionally send the message that you think your partner needs to work on their appearance. A colleague shared how her partner gifted her a treadmill “to stay fit,” which made her feel more criticised than loved. Instead, focus on gifts that highlight your partner’s strengths, like a spa day to celebrate relaxation or a gift that aligns with an activity they already enjoy.

Exercise Equipment as One of The Worst Gifts to Give on Valentine's Day

Hygiene Products

While personal hygiene is essential, gifting items like deodorant, toothpaste, or razors sends the wrong message. It can imply your partner is unclean or not meeting your standards, even if that wasn’t your intention. I remember a story about someone gifting their girlfriend a fancy soap set, which she interpreted as a subtle insult rather than a romantic gesture. We recommend choosing something indulgent, like a luxurious bath set or skincare item they’d enjoy, to ensure the gift feels pampering rather than critical.

The Worst Valentine's Day Gifts - Nothing at All

Not acknowledging Valentine's Day with any gift can be one of the most hurtful things you can do. While it might seem like a minor gesture, for many, this day is all about feeling loved and appreciated.

I once heard a story from a friend who had been in a long-term relationship, and her partner didn’t get her anything for Valentine's Day, not even a card. She felt invisible and taken for granted, which led to tension in their relationship. It's important to at least acknowledge the day with a thoughtful note or a simple gift. Even something as simple as a heartfelt card or a surprise lunch date can show your partner that you care.

The Worst Valentine's Gifts - Nothing at All

>>> See More: 20+ Free Valentines Day Gifts for Him and Her to Celebrate Love <<<

In the end, the best Valentine’s Day gifts are those that come from the heart, making your partner feel loved and cherished. By avoiding the worst Valentine’s Day gifts, you can ensure a memorable and meaningful celebration. Instead of giving generic or impersonal presents, opt for thoughtful and personalised Valentine’s Day gifts from Personal Chic that truly reflect your partner's unique personality. After all, it’s the thought that counts, and with a little care, you can make this Valentine's Day one to remember for all the right reasons.